Pre-Filing Investigation

In Denver and the Front Range of Colorado a seasoned criminal defense attorney knows there is a gap in time – before charges are filed – called “the pre-filing” stage – or the investigation stage of a case – where a good lawyer can make a major difference in the final result of the case.

At this stage in the case, if the client notifies the criminal defense lawyer of the existence of the investigation, that lawyer’s efforts may greatly alter the outcome of the case. The experienced criminal defense lawyer will initiate a series of steps to investigate and defend the case before the filing decision is made.

For example:

• The defense may interview witnesses while information is still fresh, or before witnesses move away.
• The defense may take advantage of a witnesses inconsistencies upon being questioned by a good investigator to later use that information in negotiations with the District Attorney to defend the client and to use that evidence to persuade the DA not to file charges or to file less serious charges.
• The investigation may lead to a “proffer” of the defense case to the police and the DA to establish an alibi or an alternate suspect – or to use the evidence to point out the major weaknesses in prosecutor’s case.
• Discussions with the DA may lead to a reduced charge being filed or in some cases – no charges at all being filed.
• Other negotiations may include an agreement to proceed by summons – and not arrest which would avoid the need to post bail and to suffer the humiliation of arrest.

As a former DA, H. Michael has filed hundreds if not thousands of cases for the Arapahoe / Douglas District Attorney’s office. He has successfully overseen the investigation of dozens of cases at the critical pre-filing – or investigation stage and knows the mistakes that law enforcement will make in their rushed investigations in their effort to make filing deadlines.

Attorney’s Office between 1984 and 1997. He knows what to look for in filing, and more importantly, rejecting a criminal case for finding… a process called nolle prosequi.

Never assume that because you have been arrested criminal charges will automatically be filed in court. The truth behind the scenes is that District Attorney’s have a lot of discretion in deciding which cases to charge and prosecute.

In some cases charges are inevitable and are filed, in other cases they may take up several months or longer after an arrest before making the final decision to go forward with a prosecution.

It is during this time, when the prosecutors are scrutinizing a case analyzing its strengths and weaknesses, that a criminal defense lawyer may make a difference.

If you are being investigated or have been arrested, and are awaiting charges – take the initiative, and call our firm so that we can analyze your situation and determine if “pre-filing” representation may male a difference in your case. Pre-filing representation is not always appropriate or successful in every case. However, there are certain cases where it may make an enormous difference in outcome in avoiding the expense, the embarrassment and the possible punishment of having criminal charges filed.

In Colorado, the statute of limitations – which governs how long the Government has to file charges varies with the crime investigated. For most felonies it is 3 years for some there is no statute of limitations. That means that the decision to file charges may take months if not years.

The Use of A Good Investigator

We use an excellent Colorado private investigator at our law firm who is dedicated to helping our clients immediately before criminal charges are filed in court. He and his team of investigative specialists often track down defense witnesses, and find important and relevant evidence before the police can. The resulting pre-filing investigation and intervention efforts have led to excellent results, including detained clients being released without the filing of criminal charges in court. See here.

In other words, the police initially had probable cause to arrest, but charges were not filed because the prosecutor reviewed the defense evidence and decided not to proceed with a criminal prosecution. Pre-Filing Criminal Defense success is very significant for our clients future because an arrest, without filed charges in court, means under Colorado law that a person can report on a job or licensing application that he or she has never been arrested.

Prosecutors and police can and will use your words against you. When a lawyer speaks to the DA or to the police nothing they say can be used against you. Therefore a major advantage of the pre-charging investigation is that your lawyer can contact law enforcement for you.

Law enforcement is trained and accomplished at compelling people – targets – to speak to them. They use tactics such as “we just want your side of the story” to lull you unto thinking they will be fair. Most often minds have been made up, reports are one sided, and witnesses that are exculpatory (witnesses for the defense tha offere evidence of innocence) have been ignored or not located. You will need an attorney to talk to investigators on your behalf.

Living under a “Kafkaesque” cloud of never knowing what is going on during the invesitgation can itself be unbearingly difficult and stressful. That is also a good time to consult with an attorney.

Attorney H. Michael Steinberg has a strong reputation with judges and prosecutors for defending clients in the courts of Colorado. He knows the system from the inside out as a former career prosecutor. H. Michael Steinberg has the experience and seasoning to speak the language of the police and the prosecutors. He uses those skills honed over a 26 year career as a Colorado Criminal Law Specialist, to benefit his clients.

For more information about the various defenses for your case, and to speak to H. Michael for your free consultation, contact H. Michael Steinberg at the numbers below.. He can be reached 24/7/365.